Alan {L_WROTE}:
treddly {L_WROTE}:
Projects like the Bike Tree are becoming the norm in many cities, why not get HKF to consider these at their Island Piers
HKKF doesn't own, or control the pier, beyond their gates. It's nothing to do with them.
There isn't really a problem in parking bikes on the pier. They don't impede commuters, they can walk 8 abreast along the pier.
Hong Kong is not a city that encourages cycling. The planned bike park is a porkbarrel project, an excuse for the local moguls to get a few million to pour more concrete. There is no logic, no survey of needs, no consultation with users. In other words the same as for most projects in Hong Kong.
treddly {L_WROTE}:
HKF is taking a different view now, so something has to happen
What are you talking about? If you mean the clearance of old bikes, that happens about once a year. It's not a new policy, and it's not the ferry company that does that, but the police and some government departments.
However, I expect they will inflate it into a problem as a way to justify the bike parking construction.
then what's the real problem?
is it just this :
{L_QUOTE}:
There is no logic, no survey of needs, no consultation with users. In other words the same as for most projects in Hong Kong.
If its just clearing old bikes that have been left for ages, then there isn't an issue, if, it's more than that and all bikes were culled to support the planned construction then it stinks.
If pier parked bike numbers have increased in huge amount in the past 10 years, then a better solution is needed, if not its all hot air.
You suggest it hasn't, as you say the 8 abreast thing hasn't been affected by any parked bikes... so something's afoot right?
I sympathise with the revulsion for any more expanses of concrete , and that project granted. is up many noses... so where to from here?.
For those who oppose the bike park on that basis ,why not some pre-emptive noise/stats/research/facts /figures/solutions, at least it will prove the agenda of the concrete brigade and at best YSW might succeed in getting some precedents for sensible outcomes for once.